Timeline of
the application of 3D to clocks
cliquez ici pour la version française
The table below summarizes the main milestones of the application
of 3D to clocks, mainly to tower clocks
(excluding watches or special mechanisms such as
escapements, and therefore the excellent work of John Redfern).
Since the people involved in the
Chronospédia project claim
to have originated the idea of using 3D for tower clocks,
its was my aim here to tell the truth.
I have in particular included my first (unpublished) work on 3D,
including simulations that I made around 1984-1987.
This table does however not claim to be complete and I thank all those
who will help me to complete it.
A cursory examination of the table immediately
shows that the first 3D experiments for clocks go back to the 1990s
and are therefore earlier than those of
Mr. Simon-Fustier (Chronospedia),
but even than my own. Although I have certainly not been the first
to make a 3D model of an entire clock, I may have been the first to put
online a 3D model of a tower clock in an open format
in 2020, the first to use Unity to make an interactive
clock visualization, the first to make an interactive mobile
(Android) application for a tower clock (2021),
the first to print a tower clock in 3D (2021), the first to use augmented reality for a tower clock (2022) and the first to put online a 3D version of a clock
with teeth counts metadata (2025).
I'm not particularly looking to be the first, and I'm not chasing awards, but I think others shouldn't claim to have been the first to do something if they clearly weren't.
For more information on Chronospédia and its false
rhetoric, please go to
this page.
Also, this page has an evaluation of Chronospédia through the lens of
horological know-how preservation and research.
Years |
Milestones |
Miscellaneous (selection) |
D. Roegel |
F. Simon-Fustier/Chronospedia
(all 3D models until 2022 by S. Lucchetti) |
1984-1987 |
|
First 3D (physical) simulations |
|
1990 |
|
Display of functions in 3D |
|
|
No known 3D models
of tower clocks before 1993 |
1993 |
3D model of a Morez clock in Ororbia
(Spain) (Denis Bainbridge, short animated movie
``El reloj virtual'', made with Autodesk 3D Studio) |
|
|
1994 |
Geneva horology school:
3D model of the clock of León (Spain)
(Chronométrophilia, 1994, Tell software) |
|
|
1997 |
|
First (non horological) publication
in 3D |
|
2001 |
|
First tests in 3D for
tower clock assemblies |
|
2001-2025 |
|
Various unpublished works, including
the creation of interactive viewers of 3D objects,
with animation and metadata display |
|
c2005 |
Philippe Barrilliez:
sketch of a tower clock in VRML |
|
|
2006 |
Pennestri et al., 3D model
of the Lagonegro clock (Comp. Anim. Virtual Worlds,
2006, 17: 565-572) |
|
|
2006 |
3D model of the astronomical clock
in Venice |
|
|
2007 |
|
Representation
of skew gears in descriptive geometry
(A complex drawing in descriptive geometry, TUGboat) |
|
2012 |
3D model (SolidWorks)
of the clock of the town hall
of Alcalá la Real, Jaén (Spain), by López-García,
Dávila-Rufián and Dorado-Vicente
(Proceedings of HMM2012, 2014) |
|
|
2013 |
Michel Dumain:
3D model of a Prost tower clock (Rhino) |
|
|
2013 |
Mr. Simon-Fustier
seems to have
started working in 3D in 2013, when Sébastien Lucchetti
was hired as an apprentice,
and brought with him a copy of SolidWorks.
Some places mention that work started in 2008,
but this seems spurious. |
c2013 |
|
|
First tests with Solidworks
(mechanism of the Besançon observatory) |
2014 |
|
First 3D printing of gears |
|
2015 |
Patrick Favrichon:
3D model of a Paget clock in Briançon |
|
|
2015 |
Michel Dumain:
3D model of another Prost tower clock |
|
Proposal of a 3D model for the horizontal
clock described in Diderot
and d'Alembert's Encyclopedia |
2015 |
Elisabeth Willau:
3D model for a Hörz clock (Borromäum, Salzburg)
using MicroStation from Bentley Systems |
|
|
c2016 |
Dominique Charlet:
3D model for the Rouen ``Gros Horloge'' clock
(Rhino) |
|
|
2016 |
Tristan Ledard:
3D models for the Vérité clock in Allonne
and for the old carillon clock of Beauvais |
|
|
2017 |
3D model of parts of the Strasbourg
astronomical clock (InventiveStudio, 3DSmax) |
|
3D model of the clock
of the Vaux-le-Vicomte castle |
2017 |
3D model of an E. Howard
tower clock (Autodesk) |
|
|
2018 |
|
|
3D model of the clock
of the Cluses town hall |
c2018 |
First experiments with Blender
for the Passemant clock at the Louvre
(Emmanuel Aguila, Chronos) |
|
3D viewer of the Cluses clock
based on a Three.js export of SolidWorks. |
2019 |
Michel Dumain: 3D model of
the Septmoncel tower clock |
|
3D models of the carillon clocks
of Mafra Palace (Portugal) and JSON
export for Three.js |
2019? |
3D visualization for a Habrecht clock
(Eliott Colinge, for Chronos, with Blender,
without 3D model) |
|
|
c2019 |
Frédéric Pingliez:
3D model for a Roy tower clock
(Autodesk Inventor) |
|
|
2020? |
Silvio Marugg:
3D model for the Habrecht tower clock in Schaffhausen
(SolidWorks) |
|
|
2020 |
|
3D model of Paris Notre-Dame cathedral
clock (DRCAD) online (as open STEP files) |
|
2020-2021 |
|
Using Blender for
the animation of the model of the Notre-Dame clock |
|
2020-2021 |
|
Using Unity for the
first Android application for tower clocks |
|
2020-2021 |
td>
| 3D printing of the clock of Notre-Dame
at a scale of 1/3 |
|
2021-2022 |
|
Integration of the Notre-Dame model
in augmented reality (AR) within Microsoft Hololens 2 |
|
2022 |
|
|
3D model of La Mure's city hall Odobey
clock |
2022? |
Lycée Diderot (Paris): partial 3D model of
the Trinité church (Paris) clock |
|
Experiments in augmented reality
with Oculus Rift |
2022 ? |
Jared Owen: Blender animation
for the Big Ben clock |
|
|
2023 |
Michel Dumain: 3D model of Cottet's
''geo-cosmographic'' clock |
|
Experiments with Unity |
2024 |
Michel Dumain:
Gendrey clock 3D model |
|
First tests of 3D scans of clocks |
2024 |
|
|
Eliott Colinge: Blender rendering
for a Seth Thomas' clock on behalf of Chronospédia |
2024 |
3D model of Petrovaradin's
tower clock |
|
|
30.01.2025 |
|
Notre-Dame clock online in glTF, with interactive parts and metadata |
|
05.02.2025 |
|
Notre-Dame clock in Augmented Reality (AR) using the GLB format |
|
07.02.2025 |
|
Notre-Dame clock online in glTF, with interactive parts, metadata
and motion |
|
2025 |
To this day, there does
not seem to be an Android application
for a tower clock besides the one I developed in 2021.
Also, the 3D version I put online on January 30, 2025,
seems to be the first one where a clock has metadata
such as names and teeth counts.
No other public 3D viewer showing the features of the gears
(such as the number of teeth) seems to have been made
available by others, in particular by Chronospédia.
(The Mafra viewer shows the names of the objects,
but not teeth counts.)
This feature is present in my Android application since
2021
and was in fact already present in experimental software
I developed 20 years ago. |
Denis Roegel, January 21, 2025 (first version).